Showing posts with label silent protagonist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label silent protagonist. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 29, 2014

ALL IS LOST: A Silent Monologue

In which a seventy-seven year old actor loses 60% of the hearing in his left ear because he decides to do his own stunts.


Director: J. C. Chandor
Writer: J. C. Chandor
Cast: Robert Redford
Runtime: 106 mins.
2013

All Is Lost asks the question: Why would anybody go on a boat?

The movie begins with a brief Hemingwayesque voiceover in which Robert Redford's character shares a few sparse sentiments. "I tried to be true, to be strong, to be kind, to love, to be right. But I wasn't." We don't know who he's speaking to--us? God? a loved one?--but he goes on to say that all is lost now, and that he is sorry.

This is the only significant dialogue in the entire movie, and it is dispensed with in the first thirty seconds. It's not specific, and the words aren't especially beautiful in and of themselves. But the essentialist quality of these phrases hangs over the essential action that is to follow, such that it gains much meaning and nuance and significance as we witness the eight days leading up to these words. There are many trials in this movie--the protagonist wakes to find his boat skewered by a shipping container filled with tiny sneakers, and he patches the ship up just in time to encounter a series of massive storms brewing on the horizon--but the focus is always on the man at the center of it all. Or maybe the trials are the man. And the man is the movie. It's hard to separate them.